top of page
the-boss-logo.png
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • X
  • LinkedIn
  • Youtube
  • TikTok

Time Theft in Home Care: What Agency Owners Need to Know

Writer: Alyana Cabayao
Alyana Cabayao
1 day ago
8 min read

Agency owner checking caregiver visit records

In home care, “time theft” is used for two opposite problems. One is an employee being paid for time they did not work. The other, usually called wage theft, is an agency failing to pay for time that was worked. For an owner, the second is the costlier one. Federal investigators have recovered over a million dollars at a time from agencies with sloppy timekeeping. The fix for both is the same: a clean, daily, documented record of who worked when, and a person watching it who is not you at 11 PM.



TL;DR

 

  • Time theft means two things in home care: employees claiming hours they did not work, and employers not paying for hours that were worked (wage theft). Both come from weak time records.

  • Federal law requires you to pay for all hours worked and to keep records of them. Overtime starts after 40 hours in a workweek.

  • The biggest dollar exposure is on 24-hour shifts, flat daily rates, unpaid travel between clients and hours not combined across clients.

  • Salaried and flat-rate caregivers are not a loophole. Their hours still have to be recorded and their regular rate still has to clear minimum wage.

  • Daily review of schedules, call-offs, clock-ins and missed visits catches problems early. That review is a job that should not depend on the owner.

 

Table of Contents

 

 

Two meanings of time theft in home care

 

Employee time theft is claiming pay for time not worked: clocking in late or never arriving, leaving early, stretching a visit, or logging a visit that did not happen. Agencies see it as lost margin, and sometimes as a client-safety problem when a visit is missed.

 

Wage theft is the reverse. The agency underpays by shaving hours, skipping overtime, ignoring travel time or paying a flat rate that does not cover everything worked. Workers and their lawyers use this term, and it is where the large legal judgments come from.

 

The two are linked. Agencies that fear employee time theft often lean on rigid tracking. A 2021 academic report on electronic visit verification notes that paper timesheets are increasingly seen as insufficient to guard against perceived time theft, and that rigid on/off-clock tracking struggles to capture how care work is actually done. Records that are too loose invite padding. Records that are too rigid miss real work and create underpayment. You need records that are accurate in both directions.


Two directions of time theft in home care

What the law requires you to pay for

 

Since January 1, 2015, federal minimum wage and overtime protections apply to most direct care workers. The federal minimum wage is $7.25 an hour, and a higher state rate controls where one applies. Covered workers must be paid at least 1.5 times their regular rate for hours over 40 in a workweek. Employers must keep basic time and pay records.

 

Three points trip up agencies most often.

 

“Hours worked” is broader than visit time

 

The Department of Labor’s home care guide says hours worked include all time a worker provides services or must be available to do so. Watching TV while a client naps is paid time. A break long enough for the worker’s own purposes, such as an errand, is not. The DOL’s overview for care workers adds that work you did not request but suffered or permitted is still work time.

 

Flat rates and salaries do not remove the duty to track

 

A caregiver can be paid hourly, by the day, by the shift, by monthly stipend or by salary. The DOL’s domestic service FAQ says the test is the regular rate: total weekly pay divided by total hours actually worked, which must meet at least minimum wage. Its example: $50 a day for 11 hours is a $9.09 regular rate, and that rate drives overtime past 40 hours. So a salaried nonexempt aide’s hours still must be recorded. If you do not know the hours, you cannot know the rate.

 

24-hour shifts need special care

 

For shifts of 24 hours or more, an agency and employee may agree to exclude a regularly scheduled sleep period of up to 8 hours, but only if adequate sleeping facilities are furnished, sleep is usually uninterrupted and there is an agreement. For shifts under 24 hours, the worker is paid for the entire time required at the worksite, even if allowed to sleep. Fact Sheet #79D also notes that 24-hour workers are not automatically “live-in” employees.

 

States add their own rules. New York’s Department of Labor says employers must pay home care aides 13 hours for each 24-hour shift, with at least 3 hours of break and 8 hours of sleep, 5 of them uninterrupted. California’s Household Occupations order, amended effective January 1, 2026, sets 12 consecutive hours off duty for covered live-in employees and daily overtime rules for others. Check your own state’s labor department before you set any shift structure.

 

What it has cost agencies

 

These are real enforcement outcomes, and each one traces back to timekeeping.

 

Case

What investigators found

Result

Flat daily rate for mostly 24-hour shifts, hours not tracked, sleep credit invalid

$1.1 million in back wages and damages to 69 workers

Regular rate for all hours, hours not combined across clients, travel between clients unpaid, inaccurate records

About $1.6 million to 288 workers, plus a $56,218 civil penalty for willful violations

Aides denied adequate sleep time on 24-hour shifts

$113,800 in two settlements

The pattern is consistent: no reliable record of actual hours, then a flat-rate assumption that does not survive review. Retaliation makes it worse. In a federal case in New York, the government alleges that an agency warned or fired aides who reported unpaid hours. If you suspect inaccurate reporting by an employee, handle it as a documented review of the records, not an accusation, and speak to an employment attorney before you discipline or terminate anyone.

 

Record retention matters too. The DOL guide says payroll records should be kept at least 3 years and time cards and schedules at least 2 years.


What it has cost agencies

Where time problems start in a home care office

 

Most time disputes begin in scheduling, not payroll. Four common sources:

 

  1. Unfilled and swapped shifts. A 2 AM call-off becomes a text chain, a verbal swap and a shift nobody logged properly. See our shift swap policy checklist.

  2. Double booking. Two clients scheduled for the same caregiver hour create phantom or overlapping time. Our guide on preventing double booking covers the fix.

  3. Missed or late visits. If nobody reviews clock-ins against the schedule until payroll, you pay for a visit you cannot prove. A process for audit-ready missed visit reporting closes that gap.

  4. Overtime from poor coverage. When shifts go unfilled, the same caregivers pile up hours past 40. Read how to reduce caregiver overtime.

 

Notice that none of these is solved by a stricter timesheet. They are solved by someone watching the schedule in real time, including nights and weekends, when most call-offs happen.

 

A practical time-integrity routine

 

Use this as a weekly baseline whether you run it yourself or hand it off.

 

  1. Define paid time in writing. Include travel between clients, training, waiting and on-call time, with your state’s rules for 24-hour shifts.

  2. Compare clock-ins to the schedule daily. Flag late arrivals, early departures and visits with no clock-in the next morning, not at payroll.

  3. Combine hours across clients. Overtime is counted across the workweek, not client by client.

  4. Document every call-off and swap. Who called, when, who covered and who approved.

  5. Review exceptions with the caregiver first. A missed clock-in is often a phone or app problem. Document the conversation.

  6. Keep records for the required period and make them easy to produce in an audit. Our compliance checklist for owners and employee file audit guide walk through what auditors look for.

  7. Reconcile payroll to actual hours. Month-end payroll accruals keep labor costs honest.

 

The routine is simple and it is relentless. The reason agencies skip it is that the owner is also answering the phone, filling shifts and chasing invoices.

 

Who shares responsibility for pay

 

Liability can extend beyond the agency. The National Center for Law and Economic Justice argues that managed long-term care plans are joint employers accountable for wage theft against 24-hour workers, in a suit filed in October 2024 alleging pay for only 13 hours per shift. If you contract with payers, understand how shift pay is set across the chain. For caregivers who also manage their own health coverage, plain-language material such as Medicare guidance for caregivers helps them understand costs and claims.

 

What we think about time theft

 

Owners tell us the same story. A caregiver calls off at 2 AM, the owner scrambles by text, a shift gets covered informally, and nobody writes it down properly. Two weeks later that gap shows up as overtime nobody planned or a visit nobody can prove.   We believe time integrity is an operations problem, not a trust problem. The agency that documents every call, every backfill and every schedule change the moment it happens protects its caregivers’ pay and its own margins at once.   That is why our Command Center Pod covers the phones 24/7: when a caregiver calls off, a trained team fills the shift, keeps the family calm and documents the call, and the owner is woken only for a true emergency. Our Staffing and Scheduling coordinators work in the roles that run an agency, and they know home care workflows, software and compliance.   The people reviewing your schedule should be trained in home care and not be you.   Ian Dwight Abejo

 

Getting the review off your plate

 

BOSS gives home care agency owners dedicated Pods built for the roles that keep time records clean: after-hours call coverage with real-time shift backfilling, staffing and scheduling coordination, billing and A/R, bookkeeping and HIPAA-compliant documentation. Our trained home care coordinator costs about 70% less than the same hire in-house.*


The BOSS System

 

Compared to average all-in cost of an in-house coordinator (salary, payroll taxes, benefits, admin costs). Sources: Indeed, IRS, Bureau of Labor Statistics.

 

FAQ

 

What is the difference between wage theft and time theft?

 

Time theft usually describes an employee being paid for time not worked. Wage theft describes an employer failing to pay for time that was worked, such as unpaid overtime or travel. Both depend on accurate time records.

 

Does time theft apply to salaried employees?

 

Yes, in the sense that records still matter. Under the DOL’s domestic service FAQ, a salary or flat rate is allowed only if the regular rate, pay divided by hours actually worked, meets minimum wage. Overtime applies past 40 hours for nonexempt workers.

 

Can you fire a caregiver for time theft?

 

Employers do act on falsified time records, but do it from documented evidence and consult an employment attorney first. Retaliating against workers who raise unpaid-hours concerns is an allegation at the center of a federal case, so keep reviews separate from any complaint about pay.

 

What should I do if I suspect a caregiver is padding hours?

 

Compare clock-ins, schedules, call logs and client confirmations for the dates in question. Talk to the caregiver, document the answer and apply the same rule to everyone. A daily review stops the pattern before it becomes a payroll problem.

 

Sources

 

Recommended

 

 
 
 

Comments


footer-bg-01.png
footer-bg-01.png
the-boss-logo-white.png
footer-bg-01.png
the-boss-logo-white.png

Menu

  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • TikTok
  • LinkedIn
  • Youtube

Talk to Us

332 S Michigan Ave Suite 900 Chicago,

IL 60604, USA

3rd Floor Dantess Building 236 Sto. Rosario St., Brgy. Sto Rosario, Angeles City, Pampanga

888-711-BOSS

Service Area Covered

map-white_Mesa de trabajo 1.png
footer-bg-01.png
the-boss-logo-white.png
footer-bg-01.png
the-boss-logo-white.png

Menu

  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • TikTok
  • LinkedIn
  • Youtube

Talk to Us

332 S Michigan Ave Suite 900 Chicago,

IL 60604, USA

3rd Floor Dantess Building 236 Sto. Rosario St., Brgy. Sto Rosario, Angeles City, Pampanga

888-711-BOSS

Service Area Covered

map-white_Mesa de trabajo 1.png

Schedule

meeting

Schedule

a meeting

bottom of page